New insights into the synoptic-scale predictability of 25 severe European winter storms of the 1995–2015 period are obtained using the homogeneous ensemble reforecast dataset from the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts. The predictability of the storms is assessed with different metrics including the track and intensity to investigate the storms’ dynamics and the Storm Severity Index to estimate the impact of the associated wind gusts. The storms are correctly predicted by the ensemble reforecasts up to 2–4 days ahead only, which restricts the use of ensemble average and spread to short lead times. At longer lead times, the Extreme Forecast Index and Shift of Tails are computed from the deviation of the ensemble reforecasts from the model climate. Based on these indices, the model has some skill in forecasting the area covered by extreme wind gusts up to 10 days, which indicates clear potential for the early warning of storms. However, a large variability is found between the predictability of individual storms and does not appear to be related to the storms’ characteristics. This may be due to the limited sample of 25 cases, but also suggests that each severe storm has its own dynamics and sources of forecast uncertainty.